0

Protecting people, preserving freedom.

Matt garvin

Matt Garvin, Mission Director at TasBaptists, addressed the Legislative Council on the Tasmanian Conversion Bill

Thank you for your time.

I’m Matt Garvin, Mission Director of Tasmanian Baptists. The concerns I’m raising are shared by leaders across the vast majority of Christian denominations in Tasmania, including Anglican, Catholic, Presbyterian, Reformed, Seventh-day Adventist, Pentecostal and independent churches. Leaders of other faiths are concerned too.

Kazi Sabbir, President of the Tasmanian Muslim Association, will speak after me. With us are Pastor Matt Sharples, State President of Australian Christian Churches Tasmania, and Sharon Dougherty, State Leader of Hillsong church. All four of us will be available for questions.

Let me be clear: The Christian churches and other Religious Leaders of Tasmania support protecting people from coercive, abusive and degrading practices directed at their sexual orientation or gender identity. FULL STOP.

But a good purpose needs a clear law.

Imagine a parent saying to her teenage daughter: “I love you. I don’t think you should be sleeping with your boyfriend.”

Would you expect a law against conversion practices to classify that conversation as child abuse?

I’m asking you to examine the wording that makes this a serious question. A Tasmanian parent should know where the line is drawn.

Later this morning you’ll hear a Uniting Church perspective. It deserves a hearing. In the 2021 Census, 6.8 per cent of the 213,000 Tasmanians who identified as Christian identified with the Uniting Church. However, one denomination’s position cannot override the fact that the majority of Christian churches remain deeply concerned by this legislation.

Some public statements have deepened those concerns.

In his submission to the Tasmanian Law Reform Institute, Pastor Wes Bredenhof wrote: “According to the working definition the Issues Paper provides, we are involved in SOGI conversion practices.”

He was challenging a definition that included preaching, counselling and prayer. Equality Tasmania has repeatedly publicly presented that supposed admission as evidence of current conversion practices in Tasmania. It leaves us as denominational leaders asking: are ordinary Christian practices among the things this law is intended to stop?

In the lower-house debate, Dr Rosalie Woodruff thanked Rodney Croome “for guiding us”. Equality Tasmania has every right to advocate for its community. But when one group has had a strong influence on a bill, Parliament must also hear people whose understanding of a good life is different.

That is not a criticism of Equality Tasmania for advocating for its community. It is a challenge for Parliament to hear and weigh the concerns of the whole community.

Worldviews and freedom of conscience

One of the challenges we face is that those of us who know we are speaking from a worldview often engage with people who experience their own assumptions as simply the truth.

In the current Quarterly essay Waleed Aly describes liberalism as “a master concept so fundamental we often don’t stop to name it”.

When our assumptions feel like simple truth, it can be hard to see why someone else disagrees.

The worldview I see reflected in this bill places sexual orientation or gender identity at the centre of who a person is, and sees suppressing its expression as potentially harmful.

I understand why that matters to people who have experienced shame and coercion. But it is not the only understanding of a good life.

The law should protect people from abuse without assuming that one understanding must govern everyone.

I know I bring a Christian worldview. I am asking that the understandings of identity, freedom and human flourishing shaping this Bill be made visible too. Then we can discuss them honestly, without treating disagreement as evidence of bad motives.

To make my worldview, and that of close to a third of Tasmanians, visible: Christians believe our deepest identity is found in being made and loved by God. We believe freely choosing not to act on a desire can be part of following Jesus and living well. Sometimes that means freely saying no to something we want.

Every one of us is made in the image of God and loved by him. Every one of us is also broken and in need of grace. Our pride, greed and misuse of power need confronting as much as our sexual conduct. As Nobel Prize winner and survivor of the Soviet prison camps Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn wrote “the line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either – but right through every human heart – and through all human hearts.”

We believe following Jesus is the path towards the fullest and most whole life. Heterosexuality is not the goal of Christianity. Following Jesus is. We believe the hope of the world, and every person in this room, is in Jesus.

Not everyone shares these beliefs and that is ok.

For Baptists, freedom of conscience is foundational. In 1612, Thomas Helwys argued for religious liberty for everyone: Catholics, Jews and Muslims too. Faith or Conversion cannot be compelled.

The freedom I claim belongs equally to people who reject my beliefs.

We seek shared freedom, not special privilege.

That requires respectful debate. Labelling Professor Patrick Parkinson “an entirely discredited professor” as Dr Woodruff did in the lower house debate is no substitute for answering his legal arguments. We need to play the ball, not the man.

Dr Woodruff acknowledged that not all “2000-odd emails and portal submissions” were published, citing capacity, consent and privacy. Those are real considerations. But people still need confidence that their concerns have been heard and answered.

Where the definitions lead

Now, back to the parent and daughter. Let me explain our concern.

First, the bill expands “sexual orientation” to include an “intimate or sexual relationship”, including a heterosexual relationship. The definition reaches beyond attraction to relationships.

Second, clause 5 covers “practice or conduct” directed towards a person on the basis of their orientation. A conversation can be conduct. Repetition and coercion are not express requirements of this bill.

Third, the definition includes inducing someone to suppress their orientation. But “suppress” is not defined.

If encouraging the daughter to stop sexual activity is interpreted as inducing her to suppress a relationship included within “orientation”, the wording of this bill as currently drafted says a parent is in danger of engaging in a conversion practice.

The bill adds conversion practices directed towards children to civil definitions of child abuse. If the parent’s conversation meets the conversion-practice definition, it could likely fall within those definitions.

Our concern is that conduct classified as child abuse must be clearly defined.

Or consider a man having an affair who asks his pastor for advice. If the pastor encourages him to end the relationship, that would currently meet the three-part test in the bill.

1. A practice or conduct directed towards a person;

2. On the basis of that person’s sexual orientation or gender identity; and

3. For the purpose of changing, suppressing or eradicating it, or inducing the person to do so.

We are asking for a clear distinction between suppressing an orientation and freely chosen restraint in sexual conduct.

The amendments made in the House of Assembly are welcome. But the central definition in clause 5 remains unchanged. If that definition is unclear, the uncertainty flows through the bill’s civil, criminal and regulatory consequences.

How should churches create systems to prevent conversion practices if they cannot tell which conversations they must prevent?

What about the protections we keep hearing about? The bill names parental advice, pastoral care and religious teaching. We welcome that. But the words “of itself” qualify those protections: the conduct must still be assessed against the definition.

Dr Woodruff said the qualifier “of itself” was there to prevent misuse. She said: “It was never an exemption.”

Kristie Johnston described suppression as telling someone “to be celibate, to wait, to hide, or to stop being who they are”.

Yet thousands of Tasmanians freely choose chastity or celibacy at different stages in their lives, or for their whole lives, in accordance with their faith. Anyone who believes that sex belongs within marriage, and is not married, is making that choice, and many ask for support in living out that choice.

The law needs to distinguish that support from a conversion practice.

Three changes for a clearer law

We ask for three changes.

First, and most importantly, define “suppress” clearly, distinguishing suppression of orientation or identity from freely chosen restraint in sexual conduct.

Second, replace the uncertainty of “of itself” with effective protection for ordinary religious expression, parental guidance and voluntary pastoral care, while preserving prohibitions on abuse.

Third, focus the definition on serious or substantial harmful practices.

Later this morning you will hear about harm people have experienced, and you should listen carefully. We too are grieved by harm that has happened in the past.

Nobody is arguing for harmful practices.

You will also hear from people who believe the bill needs no change. You may also hear that ordinary teaching, prayer and parental guidance are already protected.

Our question is not whether those protections were intended. It is whether the words on the page actually provide them.

Please test our concerns against the wording of the bill and not just the opinions of the bill’s proponents.

If you can’t be sure then how can a parent, a pastor or someone seeking support know with confidence where the line is drawn?

This is about more than a legal definition. It is about whether people with deeply different convictions can trust that there is a place for them in the same society.

Trust suffers when people believe decisions about their deepest convictions have been made without understanding how those decisions affect their lives.

Please give us a law that protects people from abuse and leaves room for competing worldviews.

Kazi and I disagree about Jesus and other religious teachings. We can remain friends and seek each other’s freedom.

Our neighbours do not have to share our hope in Jesus.

We ask for freedom to offer it, and for people to seek it freely.

Thank you. Kazi will now speak.

Further reading

For the earlier discussion behind this presentation, see Dear Cecily Rosol: Tasmania’s Conversion Practices Bill.

Handout for members

Download the full handout for members of the Legislative Council (PDF).

Image: Matt Garvin. Image Credit: Citywide Baptist Church

Uncategorised

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *