0

Erasure, competing rights and Karen Pack

karen pack

Speaking as an historian, Dr Karen Pack, also a preacher, former missionary, and former theological lecturer, gave the 2026 Movement for the Ordination of Women (MOW) conference a tour of Australian Christian history texts and their pronounced tendency to omit women. The gender ratios of the major history books she compared ran from one woman for 63 men to the best ratio, one in five.

The accounts of the women’s ordination battles in the Anglican church – a focus for the MOW audience – amazingly continued the discrepancy, with Pack citing the omission of the names of ordinands from the accounts by male authors, even while MOW leaders were in some cases named.

Pack sketched out the lives of two women given fuller biographies in Queer Omissions. She argued that Francis Deborah Levvy (1831 – 1924), a major campaigner against cruelty to animals, was in fact a public theologian, and her work should be recognised by Anglicans (her denomination) in particular.

Similarly, Ada Constance Duncan (1896-1970), a lifelong Baptist and missionary, a welfare worker, an internationalist, a refugee advocate, and a social reformer, while better known than Levvy, did not receive a mention in the standard religious histories apart from brief mentions in accounts of the YWCA and other organisations. In Queer Omissions, Pack noted that she has found no published obituary of Duncan. 

For this observer, Pack’s account of moving into the Hillsong Church, from the Women’s-Ordination-friendly Salvation Army in her teens, was revelatory.

Pack described “incredible pressure to conform to gender norms and specifically to be married and to have children.” She said that the doctrine of male headship was taught” creating a real dissonance “between the apparent promotion of women in leadership and the clear expectation that they would submit to their husbands.”

Pack provided the case that Australian Christianity has excluded women in many ways, quite apart from Ordination.

Alongside her talk on exclusion, Pack was a lively contributor to a MOW panel discussion on promoting the inclusion of women while a missionary in Burkina Faso. Her skill as an expositor and advocate was on full display.

Reflecting on Karen Pack’s presentation on forgotten women, and erasure from history at the 2026 MOW conference, instills the thought on this observer of a double effect. Karen Pack is herself both excluded (regarding her sacking from Morling College) and unlikely to be erased from history.

For example, when Community Strong Member for Wentworth Allegra Spender introduced her Sex Discrimination and Fair Work Amendment (Equality in Treatment in Religious Schools) Bill 2026 she “highlighted the case of Dr Karen Pack, who, as a senior teacher at Morling College, was dismissed from her position in 2020 after marrying her same-sex partner,” according to OUT in Perth.

“Most Australians would be surprised that under federal law today, a religious school or university can still sack a teacher or expel a student simply because they are gay, transgender, divorced or pregnant. State protections vary, but federal law still allows it, Spender said in her speech introducing her bill…

“Karen Pack, who is in the gallery today, is an ordained minister and was a senior lecturer at Morling College, a Baptist college in Sydney. The college itself called her an ‘excellent and committed educator’ with a ‘deep and abiding faith’. She was fired in April 2020 after getting engaged to her same-sex partner. In her words:

‘For most people, announcing their engagement means congratulations. For me it meant getting fired.’

“Karen still has a deep and abiding faith. Her sexuality does not erase that.”

Ross Clifford, then principal at Morling, has told the Other Cheek that his and the college’s objection to Pack being on staff was that she would teach a different Christianity.

In the time since Pack was teaching at Morling, the NSW ACT Baptist Association has adopted a “position statement” against same-sex marriage and measures to have ministers and congregations assent to it.

Several churches have left the Baptist Association and have become part of a new group, the Open Baptists.

Should the Baptist association – or the Catholics, Anglicans and Pentecostals – and Muslims have the ability to hold that ministers or imams and those training them to hold to their doctrinal positions. This would seem to be 

At the MOW conference, Karen Pack discussed with The Other Cheek the fact she stands at the centre of competing rights: religious freedom and LGBTQIA rights. While she is a strong, capable person, it must take a toll. She has stated that she thinks we should be able to get past this impasse.

The Other Cheek does not know how.

Because the Karen Pack case is the hardest case of all: a lecturer at a seminary or theological college.

To insist that churches hire people who teach their ministers who teach against the doctrine of the denomination or network auspicing the college is to radically diminish religious freedom.

Schools, to this writer’s mind, are different. Networks like Christian Schools Australia insist that schools do not expel gay students. The Other Cheek is not sure about this; CSA and the others do not speak for all schools and, given the enrolment contracts of some schools, an outspoken gay student might be asked to leave technically for behavioural reasons. 

Schools can surely teach christian doctrine gently while being aware they have non-believers among them, students certainly, but also staff. It seems to this observer that the spender Bill is outrageously tight on staffing – with only Principals and chaplains included as being able to be selected for promotion on religious grounds. A compromise might be that schools should be able to require a percentage, maybe half, of their teaching staff to be believers, teach religion, and be trained to do that. This compromise will annoy secularists and religious freedom extremists alike, The Other Cheek suspects.

But it doesn’t solve the Karen Pack and Morling case. History, ironically perhaps, has now guaranteed Pack that she won’t be erased, but equally she has more interesting things to say than her own case study.

Karen Pack, Queer Omissions: Unmarried Women and Social Justice Activism in the Church. Routledge, 2025. Available from Routledge: $69.74

Main Image: Karen Pack. Image Credit www.un-packed.com.au

Shortened a direct quote at the request of MOW

Uncategorised

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *