1

Andrew Sedra dreams of a big church, so he preaches that God wants his small congregation to pay and pay

Sedra sermon on money

SavedGoals92Overall score

1,567 words

“What are you actually believing God for?” Pastor Andrew Sedra asked Echoe Church last Sunday. “What are you actually going for? But today I want to flip the script and change the narrative. It’s not what do you want, but what does God want from you this season?”

The answer the sermon made clear was money. Lots of money.

“I want you to look at the text in Hebrews 11 with me for a moment because faith hopes and then faith offers and then faith builds and then faith sacrifices. This is the evolution of faith. It goes from hope to sacrifice, from sacrifice to building and from building to offering to the Lord, because we live in a moment of time where people like singing and singing.

Why mention singing? Because Pastor Sedra is mocking his fellow Pentecostals. 

“We are a country that is known for singing. Australians love to sing for Jesus. People, he like to sing on the hills and they like to sing to shake the planet.” Sedra, in a mocking tone, alludes to Hillsong and Planetshakers.

“We love singing and singing, we don’t like the sacrificing. We like the praying and the praying, but we don’t like the giving. We like the worshipping , the worshipping, but we don’t like the offering. Even though Paul said it this way, I plead with you brothers and sisters to offer your life as a living sacrifice. This is true worship.”

We’ll get to how Sedra twists the notion of sacrifice – but first, why knock other Pentecostal Churches?

Because Sedra needs the congregation to feel that they especially are followers of Christ, that they have insights other churches don’t have. Because he is working up to a big ask, based on an idiosyncratic theology of sacrifice, and putting the church in the place of the Temple, the place of sacrifice”

“Look what Second Chronicles said: ‘If my people who are called by my name will humble themselves and pray and seek my face.’ But look at the practical part of the text because God didn’t just come, and the gospel didn’t just rock up.

“Look what it said. It said then one night the Lord appeared to Solomon. He said, ‘I’ve heard your prayer and I have chosen this house as a place of making sacrifices.’ God is saying, ‘I have chosen this house.’ I have chosen my house. What is the purpose of the house? As a place, as a space of making sacrifices.”

“Some of you don’t know what church is. That’s the point of the church. I have chosen this house. Some of you need to like [have] a brain transplant if that is possible. I have chosen this house as a place and a space of making sacrifices. And then after, then and only then if my people who are called by my name will humble themselves to pray and seek my face and turn and said I will hear from heaven. And restolderland because this is how God will save Sydney, Australia. This is how God will save Brisbane and Australia. This is [God’s way] to save Gold Coast, Canberra, Ulladulla, Orroroo, Watanga forever, Williammongong.”

Sacrifice needs to take place at the church, Sedra preaches. And as the sermon continues, it is clear it is a monetary sacrifice that is called for. A big one.

Addressing a church with an average attendance of under 200 people (and with Sedra’s maths indicating he expects the big bucks from 140 people), he asks for a “breakthrough offering”

“This breakthrough offering where I think, $350,000, which is a very doable goal. I’m a practical type of man because the Bible says the king prepares for battle, but victory comes from the Lord. So I like to break big goals into little goals. If every single person in this house next weekend offered and sacrificed to the Lord $2,500, that goal will be met very easy.

“If every single family in this home, in this house next weekend gave and sacrificed $5,000, it will happen because the Bible says where the king prepares for battle, but victory comes from the Lord.”

“

See, Muslims need to sacrifice their own life to kill the infidel. Jezebels and feminists need to sacrifice their own actual baby to the evil, wicked, demon God of Molech. And the exact same way as the Christians and the people of God, we don’t need to sacrifice our children. We don’t need to kill babies. We just need to bring the fruit of the work of our hand. We just need to sacrifice. We just need to work, work, work and work, work, work and give, give, give, give. We just need to sacrifice, sacrifice, sacrifice in order to build the kingdom of God.”

What is Sedra raising the money for? After mentioning all those Aussie place names, he adds, “This is how God will save this nation. It’s through the offering of the sacrifice. This is also how God will save Orlando and Central Florida.” And later, “You find this vision of God can save Australia, and God can save Orlando.” Orlando, Florida – which is an interesting place for the people of Southwest Sydney to be raising money for.

Earlier in the sermon, Sedra says, “You go to Texas and America, there’s big, big, massive churches and big, big, massive houses. There is a correlation between building God’s house and having a bigger country, a better country and a greater country. This is what the Bible said. The world of the stingy gets smaller and smaller, and the world of the godly gets bigger and bigger.”

Sedra’s brother John is currently preaching in the US. And the Sedra brothers Andrew and Martin have returned from a preaching tour (or two).

They want a breakthrough – to a big church. Maybe in Australia, or the US. But a big church appears to be what they want.

And the way to get there seems to be to preach Sacrifice in a warehouse in Smeaton Grange near Campbelltown, Sydney.

Hence a theology of Sacrifice.

Using the sacrificial system of the Old Testament short-circuits the gospel. Jesus, as the author of the book of Hebrews explains, is our high priest who, by his own sacrificial offering, has done away with the offering of bulls and goats, pigeons and doves. Jesus’ sacrifice was once for all.

The sacrifices in the temple were to atone for sin, not to build a bigger temple. By the time Solomon’s temple was consecrated, the people had donated gold and silver, and King Hiram had floated the cedar logs down from Lebanon. The sacrifices were sin offerings.

The difficulty with the Sedra appeal for money, for breakthrough:

  1. It is an example of Christian leaders lording themselves over their flock by placing demands on them.
  2. There seems to be no regard for individual circumstances. It is simply assumed everyone can produce $25,000 that week
  3. There’s the prosperity gospel.

When it comes to Romans 12:1 that Sedra cites – “Therefore, I urge you, brothers and sisters, in view of God’s mercy, to offer your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy and pleasing to God—this is your true and proper worship” is our generous response to God’s generosity. 

Sedra turns this around – God’s generosity depends on our generosity. Sedra also changes God’s generosity into something like an ATM. You put money in and with interest you can get more out. Yet God’s generosity is not earthbound, it is also eschatological – his promises to repay extend into eternity. But Sedra squeezes God into an ATM sized hole in the wall.

Sedra claims not to be a prosperity gospel preacher, but judge for yourself.

“Proverbs 11:24: give freely, become more wealthy. This is not prosperity gospel. This is biblical wisdom. Be stingy and lose everything. The generous shall prosper. You can never outgive God, and God will only give it to you if he can pass it through you and God can only give you what he will entrust you with to give away because those who plant with tears, planting meaning sacrifice again above and beyond in the soil of the eternal kingdom of God, because some of you, you’re not planting in the kingdom of God and that is why you’re not getting kingdom result because you can never outgive God. I’m here to tell you, next weekend, as you bring the $350,000, as you bring the work of your hand, as you bring the toil of your labour, as you bring your sweat, blood and tears, you can never outgive God.

“And this is a test and this is a test. The Bible said it this way. ‘Running over.’ It says your gift will return in full. Your gift, because you’re not more… It is the dumbest thing in the world when you see the Lord building his church and for you to not give sacrificially above and beyond again and again. I mean to tell you, it is so stupid. It is so dumb because some of you have been planting seeds in the kingdom of your business. Some of you have been planting seeds in the empire of your world, but you haven’t planted seeds in the kingdom of God and you will not be able to harvest any blessing because you’ve got to plant something. The Bible said it this way, you cannot mock the justice of God. You will always harvest while you plant.”

It’s a con. It is a Pentecostal version of indulgences. It is a return to Old Testament law of sacrifice. Instead of grace, Sedra imposes financial burdens on his block.

Image: Andrew Sedra preaching on sacrifice and money. Image credit: Echo Church YouTube screenshot

UPDATE: One perceptive reader, commented that we should be careful not to jettison verses like

– Philippians 4:18 “the gifts you sent … are a fragrant offering, an acceptable *sacrifice* pleasing to God”

– 2 Corinthians 9:6-8 “Remember this: Whoever sows sparingly will also reap sparingly, and whoever sows generously will also reap generously… God is able to bless you abundantly, so that in all things at all times, having all that you need, you will abound in every good work.”

He commented that churches will often mention an average dollar amount they are requesting. And that churches will often say things like, “for some, generosity really looks like giving a lot more than that, while for others you may not be able to give that amount.”

The Other Cheek appreciates the pushback. But notes that such a statement is missing from the Sedra sermon. In addition, the Sedras were suggesting payment by the following weekend, an urgency not normal in churches. Paul does not state that funds will be replenished or increased, but that God’s abundance will give us what we need.

Change: reader in the comment above anonymised at their request.

One Comment

  1. Thankyou for shining a light on this… There is so much that has been hidden. Especially in this place.

Comments are closed.